Soft/Governance & Integrity/Political Institutions & Civic Participation

Legislature & Deliberative Institutions

The capacity to deliberate and constrain: a legislature with the committees, analytical support and scrutiny powers to make law well and hold the executive to account.
pending/cap/legislature-deliberative-institutions
World mean
8.7
of 20 · median 8.0
Range
1–18
middle half 6.0–12.0
Panel SD
±0.39
round 1 ±1.12 — the honest estimate
Leader
18
Germany, United Kingdom, United States

Indicators

The measures seeded for this capability in the framework. They are candidate indicators: no cell in the index has a source document attached to it yet.

Band spread across 197 nations

Frontier 3
Advanced 19
Established 30
Transitional 42
Foundational 56
Nascent 33
Inception 14

All 197 nations

Best first. The score is the mean of the four adjudicators' round-3 integers, rounded to the nearest integer; ±SD is their spread on that cell. Where the spread is three points or more, read the number as a band rather than a value.

#NationRegionScoreBandPanel SD
1 🇩🇪Germany Europe 18 Frontier ±0.50
2 🇬🇧United Kingdom Europe 18 Frontier ±0.50
3 🇺🇸United States Americas 18 Frontier ±0.50
4 🇦🇺Australia Asia Pacific 17 Advanced ±0.00
5 🇨🇦Canada Americas 17 Advanced ±0.43
6 🇩🇰Denmark Europe 17 Advanced ±0.00
7 🇫🇮Finland Europe 17 Advanced ±0.00
8 🇳🇱Netherlands Europe 17 Advanced ±0.00
9 🇳🇿New Zealand Asia Pacific 17 Advanced ±0.43
10 🇳🇴Norway Europe 17 Advanced ±0.00
11 🇸🇪Sweden Europe 17 Advanced ±0.43
12 🇨🇭Switzerland Europe 17 Advanced ±0.50
13 🇦🇹Austria Europe 16 Advanced ±0.43
14 🇧🇪Belgium Europe 16 Advanced ±0.43
15 🇫🇷France Europe 16 Advanced ±0.83
16 🇯🇵Japan Asia Pacific 16 Advanced ±0.00
17 🇰🇷South Korea Asia Pacific 16 Advanced ±0.43
18 🇹🇼Taiwan Asia Pacific 16 Advanced ±0.50
19 🇪🇪Estonia Europe 15 Advanced ±0.50
20 🇮🇸Iceland Europe 15 Advanced ±0.00
21 🇮🇪Ireland Europe 15 Advanced ±0.00
22 🇪🇸Spain Europe 15 Advanced ±0.00
23 🇧🇷Brazil Americas 14 Established ±0.00
24 🇨🇱Chile Americas 14 Established ±0.00
25 🇨🇿Czechia Europe 14 Established ±0.00
26 🇮🇱Israel Middle East 14 Established ±0.00
27 🇮🇹Italy Europe 14 Established ±0.00
28 🇱🇻Latvia Europe 14 Established ±0.43
29 🇱🇹Lithuania Europe 14 Established ±0.43
30 🇱🇺Luxembourg Europe 14 Established ±0.00
31 🇵🇹Portugal Europe 14 Established ±0.00
32 🇸🇮Slovenia Europe 14 Established ±0.00
33 🇿🇦South Africa Africa 14 Established ±0.50
34 🇺🇾Uruguay Americas 14 Established ±0.00
35 🇨🇷Costa Rica Americas 13 Established ±0.00
36 🇱🇮Liechtenstein Europe 13 Established ±0.50
37 🇲🇹Malta Europe 13 Established ±0.50
38 🇵🇱Poland Europe 13 Established ±0.00
39 🇸🇰Slovakia Europe 13 Established ±0.43
40 🇦🇷Argentina Americas 12 Established ±0.43
41 🇧🇬Bulgaria Europe 12 Established ±0.43
42 🇨🇴Colombia Americas 12 Established ±0.43
43 🇭🇷Croatia Europe 12 Established ±0.00
44 🇨🇾Cyprus Middle East 12 Established ±0.00
45 🇬🇷Greece Europe 12 Established ±0.00
46 🇮🇳India Asia Pacific 12 Established ±0.43
47 🇲🇺Mauritius Africa 12 Established ±0.00
48 🇲🇽Mexico Americas 12 Established ±0.71
49 🇷🇴Romania Europe 12 Established ±0.43
50 🇸🇲San Marino Europe 12 Established ±0.43
51 🇸🇬Singapore Asia Pacific 12 Established ±1.23
52 🇺🇦Ukraine Europe 12 Established ±0.43
53 🇦🇩Andorra Europe 11 Transitional ±0.43
54 🇧🇧Barbados Americas 11 Transitional ±0.43
55 🇧🇼Botswana Africa 11 Transitional ±0.00
56 🇨🇻Cabo Verde Africa 11 Transitional ±0.50
57 🇩🇴Dominican Republic Americas 11 Transitional ±0.50
58 🇬🇭Ghana Africa 11 Transitional ±0.00
59 🇮🇩Indonesia Asia Pacific 11 Transitional ±0.43
60 🇯🇲Jamaica Americas 11 Transitional ±0.00
61 🇰🇪Kenya Africa 11 Transitional ±0.43
62 🇲🇾Malaysia Asia Pacific 11 Transitional ±0.43
63 🇹🇹Trinidad & Tobago Americas 11 Transitional ±0.43
64 🇦🇱Albania Europe 10 Transitional ±0.43
65 🇧🇸Bahamas Americas 10 Transitional ±0.00
66 🇭🇺Hungary Europe 10 Transitional ±0.00
67 🇲🇩Moldova Europe 10 Transitional ±0.43
68 🇲🇳Mongolia Asia Pacific 10 Transitional ±0.43
69 🇲🇪Montenegro Europe 10 Transitional ±0.43
70 🇳🇦Namibia Africa 10 Transitional ±0.83
71 🇲🇰North Macedonia Europe 10 Transitional ±0.83
72 🇵🇦Panama Americas 10 Transitional ±0.43
73 🇵🇪Peru Americas 10 Transitional ±0.00
74 🇵🇭Philippines Asia Pacific 10 Transitional ±0.43
75 🇸🇳Senegal Africa 10 Transitional ±0.43
76 🇷🇸Serbia Europe 10 Transitional ±0.83
77 🇸🇨Seychelles Africa 10 Transitional ±0.43
78 🇱🇰Sri Lanka Asia Pacific 10 Transitional ±0.43
79 🇹🇷Türkiye Middle East 10 Transitional ±0.50
80 🇦🇬Antigua & Barbuda Americas 9 Transitional ±0.00
81 🇦🇲Armenia Middle East 9 Transitional ±0.43
82 🇧🇿Belize Americas 9 Transitional ±0.00
83 🇧🇴Bolivia Americas 9 Transitional ±0.87
84 🇩🇲Dominica Americas 9 Transitional ±0.43
85 🇪🇨Ecuador Americas 9 Transitional ±0.00
86 🇬🇪Georgia Middle East 9 Transitional ±0.00
87 🇳🇬Nigeria Africa 9 Transitional ±0.00
88 🇵🇰Pakistan Asia Pacific 9 Transitional ±0.00
89 🇵🇾Paraguay Americas 9 Transitional ±0.00
90 🇸🇷Suriname Americas 9 Transitional ±0.43
91 🇹🇿Tanzania Africa 9 Transitional ±0.87
92 🇹🇭Thailand Asia Pacific 9 Transitional ±0.83
93 🇺🇬Uganda Africa 9 Transitional ±0.87
94 🇿🇲Zambia Africa 9 Transitional ±0.00
95 🇧🇹Bhutan Asia Pacific 8 Foundational ±0.43
96 🇧🇦Bosnia & Herzegovina Europe 8 Foundational ±0.71
97 🇫🇯Fiji Asia Pacific 8 Foundational ±0.43
98 🇬🇩Grenada Americas 8 Foundational ±0.00
99 🇬🇾Guyana Americas 8 Foundational ±0.43
100 🇽🇰Kosovo Europe 8 Foundational ±0.43
101 🇲🇼Malawi Africa 8 Foundational ±0.43
102 🇲🇻Maldives Asia Pacific 8 Foundational ±0.43
103 🇲🇦Morocco Africa 8 Foundational ±0.43
104 🇳🇵Nepal Asia Pacific 8 Foundational ±0.00
105 🇵🇼Palau Asia Pacific 8 Foundational ±0.43
106 🇰🇳Saint Kitts & Nevis Americas 8 Foundational ±0.43
107 🇱🇨Saint Lucia Americas 8 Foundational ±0.00
108 🇻🇨Saint Vincent & Grenadines Americas 8 Foundational ±0.00
109 🇼🇸Samoa Asia Pacific 8 Foundational ±0.87
110 🇹🇱Timor-Leste Asia Pacific 8 Foundational ±0.00
111 🇹🇴Tonga Asia Pacific 8 Foundational ±0.87
112 🇧🇩Bangladesh Asia Pacific 7 Foundational ±0.43
113 🇧🇯Benin Africa 7 Foundational ±0.43
114 🇨🇳China Asia Pacific 7 Foundational ±0.87
115 🇨🇮Côte d'Ivoire Africa 7 Foundational ±0.43
116 🇬🇲Gambia Africa 7 Foundational ±0.43
117 🇬🇹Guatemala Americas 7 Foundational ±0.00
118 🇭🇳Honduras Americas 7 Foundational ±0.43
119 🇯🇴Jordan Middle East 7 Foundational ±0.87
120 🇰🇬Kyrgyzstan Asia Pacific 7 Foundational ±0.50
121 🇱🇸Lesotho Africa 7 Foundational ±0.50
122 🇲🇬Madagascar Africa 7 Foundational ±0.50
123 🇵🇬Papua New Guinea Asia Pacific 7 Foundational ±0.43
124 🇷🇼Rwanda Africa 7 Foundational ±0.87
125 🇸🇹São Tomé & Príncipe Africa 7 Foundational ±0.00
126 🇸🇱Sierra Leone Africa 7 Foundational ±0.43
127 🇸🇧Solomon Islands Asia Pacific 7 Foundational ±0.87
128 🇹🇳Tunisia Africa 7 Foundational ±0.87
129 🇹🇻Tuvalu Asia Pacific 7 Foundational ±0.00
130 🇻🇺Vanuatu Asia Pacific 7 Foundational ±0.43
131 🇩🇿Algeria Africa 6 Foundational ±0.83
132 🇦🇴Angola Africa 6 Foundational ±0.43
133 🇪🇬Egypt Africa 6 Foundational ±0.43
134 🇸🇻El Salvador Americas 6 Foundational ±0.43
135 🇪🇹Ethiopia Africa 6 Foundational ±0.43
136 🇮🇷Iran Asia Pacific 6 Foundational ±0.83
137 🇮🇶Iraq Middle East 6 Foundational ±0.00
138 🇰🇿Kazakhstan Asia Pacific 6 Foundational ±0.87
139 🇰🇮Kiribati Asia Pacific 6 Foundational ±0.00
140 🇰🇼Kuwait Middle East 6 Foundational ±0.43
141 🇱🇧Lebanon Middle East 6 Foundational ±0.43
142 🇱🇷Liberia Africa 6 Foundational ±0.00
143 🇲🇭Marshall Islands Asia Pacific 6 Foundational ±0.43
144 🇫🇲Micronesia Asia Pacific 6 Foundational ±0.43
145 🇲🇨Monaco Europe 6 Foundational ±0.83
146 🇲🇿Mozambique Africa 6 Foundational ±0.43
147 🇷🇺Russia Europe 6 Foundational ±1.23
148 🇹🇬Togo Africa 6 Foundational ±0.43
149 🇻🇳Vietnam Asia Pacific 6 Foundational ±0.43
150 🇿🇼Zimbabwe Africa 6 Foundational ±0.71
151 🇦🇿Azerbaijan Middle East 5 Nascent ±0.87
152 🇧🇭Bahrain Middle East 5 Nascent ±0.43
153 🇧🇮Burundi Africa 5 Nascent ±0.50
154 🇰🇭Cambodia Asia Pacific 5 Nascent ±0.43
155 🇨🇲Cameroon Africa 5 Nascent ±0.43
156 🇰🇲Comoros Africa 5 Nascent ±0.50
157 🇨🇬Congo Africa 5 Nascent ±0.43
158 🇨🇩DR Congo Africa 5 Nascent ±0.43
159 🇲🇷Mauritania Africa 5 Nascent ±0.43
160 🇳🇷Nauru Asia Pacific 5 Nascent ±0.00
161 🇧🇫Burkina Faso Africa 4 Nascent ±0.83
162 🇹🇩Chad Africa 4 Nascent ±0.50
163 🇨🇺Cuba Americas 4 Nascent ±0.71
164 🇩🇯Djibouti Africa 4 Nascent ±0.50
165 🇸🇿Eswatini Africa 4 Nascent ±0.43
166 🇬🇦Gabon Africa 4 Nascent ±0.50
167 🇱🇦Laos Asia Pacific 4 Nascent ±0.50
168 🇲🇱Mali Africa 4 Nascent ±0.50
169 🇳🇮Nicaragua Americas 4 Nascent ±0.50
170 🇴🇲Oman Middle East 4 Nascent ±0.83
171 🇶🇦Qatar Middle East 4 Nascent ±0.83
172 🇸🇦Saudi Arabia Middle East 4 Nascent ±0.87
173 🇸🇴Somalia Africa 4 Nascent ±0.00
174 🇦🇪United Arab Emirates Middle East 4 Nascent ±0.71
175 🇺🇿Uzbekistan Asia Pacific 4 Nascent ±0.43
176 🇧🇾Belarus Europe 3 Nascent ±0.71
177 🇨🇫Central African Rep. Africa 3 Nascent ±0.43
178 🇬🇳Guinea Africa 3 Nascent ±0.00
179 🇬🇼Guinea-Bissau Africa 3 Nascent ±0.00
180 🇵🇸Palestine Middle East 3 Nascent ±0.43
181 🇸🇸South Sudan Africa 3 Nascent ±0.43
182 🇹🇯Tajikistan Asia Pacific 3 Nascent ±0.71
183 🇻🇪Venezuela Americas 3 Nascent ±0.00
184 🇧🇳Brunei Asia Pacific 2 Inception ±0.71
185 🇬🇶Equatorial Guinea Africa 2 Inception ±0.00
186 🇱🇾Libya Africa 2 Inception ±0.00
187 🇳🇪Niger Africa 2 Inception ±0.71
188 🇸🇩Sudan Africa 2 Inception ±0.50
189 🇸🇾Syria Middle East 2 Inception ±0.43
190 🇹🇲Turkmenistan Asia Pacific 2 Inception ±0.43
191 🇾🇪Yemen Middle East 2 Inception ±0.50
192 🇦🇫Afghanistan Asia Pacific 1 Inception ±0.50
193 🇪🇷Eritrea Africa 1 Inception ±0.00
194 🇭🇹Haiti Americas 1 Inception ±0.43
195 🇻🇦Holy See Europe 1 Inception ±0.43
196 🇲🇲Myanmar Asia Pacific 1 Inception ±0.71
197 🇰🇵North Korea Asia Pacific 1 Inception ±0.43

Others in Political Institutions & Civic Participation

CapabilityWorld meanRangeLeader
Electoral Management & Integrity9.80–18Australia, Canada, Denmark
Citizen Participation & Civic Space8.60–18Finland, Sweden, Switzerland